New York City
Bagel Story
1237 Fulton St, Brooklyn, New York 11216, United States
3.5156 on Google
Photo by Ai Hao via Google
Photo by Ai Hao via Google
Photo by Rebecca Appel via Google- Photo by Rebecca Appel via Google
What people say
Bagel Story serves fresh, generously buttered bagels in a chill spot with friendly service. Execution is inconsistent—some reviewers rave about their orders, others found quality fell short of expectations.
Known for
- fresh toasted bagels
- generous butter portions
- friendly cashier
- quiet, chill vibe
- outlets under tables
Heads up
- quality and portions vary significantly between orders
- no bathroom on-site
Synthesized by Claude from 5 Google reviews.
Tagged for
- Open early
- Open weekends
- Pastries
- Fresh bread
Best Thing on the Menu
Nobody's voted yet